Tuesday, November 19, 2013

Dr. Clay Nichols testifies

WRAL's continuing coverage of the Mangum murder trial had Dr. Clay Nichols' testimony today.

Nichols was a Medical Examiner with the North Carolina State Medical Examiner's Office. He performed the autopsy on the late Reginald Daye. The most important part of Nichols' testimony was on direct examination where he read his conclusion - Daye died as a result of a stab wound. That combined with Mangum's self defense posture proves the state's case. (She has admitted stabbing Daye.) Now Nichols has given evidence that the stab would caused Daye's untimely demise.

Dr. Nichols also identified, without objection, defensive wounds on Daye's left arm. This will figure in the state's closing argument, if the ADA is worth her law degree.

Daniel Meier, the defense counsel did a good job of cross examining Nichols. He pointed out the inconsistencies between Nichols' findings and the medical records. Specifically Meier pointed out the lack of report on the lung wound or the kidney wound. He brought up the issue of a chest tube. Nichols said very plainly that there were wounds that were sutured regardless of what the post operative report did not say. He also said there was no chest tube in the left side. All told, Nichols was very convincing in his presentation.

Now, the defense will have to bring an expert to attempt to refute Nichols' testimony. However, we know from the breach of attorney - client confidentiality by a supposed supporter of Mangum's that the defense expert agrees with Dr. Nichols. Thus, it will be very difficult for the defense to make a case for an intervening cause.

No comments:

Post a Comment